PUBLIC
`
`D=8C43 BC0C4B 8=C4A=0C8>=0; CA034 2><<8BB8>=
`F0B78=6C>=$ 3&2& (’*)+
`
`8U [QN <J[[NY VO
`
`24AC08= 0DC><0C43 C4;;4A
`<0278=4B$ 0C< <>3D;4B$
`2><?>=4=CB C74A4>5$ 0=3
`?A>3D2CB 2>=C08=8=6 C74 B0<4
`
`8U]NZ[RPJ[RVU =V& )),%C0%.-.
`
`>??>B8C8>= C> 3841>;3cB <>C8>= 5>A
`BC0G >5 A4<4380; >A34AB ?4=38=6 0??40;
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`C01;4 >5 2>=C4=CB
`
`?JPN
`
`CHNLI>O=NCIH ***************************************************************************************************************************-
`
`C*
`
`CC*
`
`JLI=?>OL;F BCMNILS*************************************************************************************************/
`
`@IOL)@;=NIL N?MN @IL GINCIHM NI MN;S J?H>CHA ;JJ?;F***********************0
`
`;*
`
`>C?<IF> @;CFM NI C>?HNC@S ;H u;>GCNN?>FS >C@@C=OFN F?A;F
`KO?MNCIHv************************************************************************************************************1
`
`^*
`
`^^*
`
`DjY\Z M]Vlxh VcY i]Z =dbb^hh^dcxh @VXijVa @^cY^c\h LZ\VgY^c\ u=]ZfjZ
`MiVcYWn Oc^iv ;gZ MjeedgiZY Wn MjWhiVci^Va ?k^YZcXZ***********************************3
`
`DjY\Z M]Vlxh VcY i]Z =dbb^hh^dcxh @VXijVa @^cY^c\h LZaViZY id u<jcYaZ
`MZeVgVidgv ;gZ MjeedgiZY Wn MjWhiVci^Va ?k^YZcXZ*****************************************4
`
`<*
`
`=*
`
`>*
`
`>C?<IF>xM ;FF?A?> B;LG CM MJ?=OF;NCP?******************************************--
`
`BSIMOHA QIOF> <? B;LG?> <S MN;SCHA NB? CHDOH=NCIH *********-.
`
`NB? JO<FC= CHN?L?MN >I?M HIN MOJJILN ; MN;S ******************************-/
`
`=IH=FOMCIH******************************************************************************************************************************-0
`
`^
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`C01;4 >5 0DC7>A8C84B
`
`?JPN"Z#
`
`2JZNZ
`
`-QGY’ 5OE) W) >CSKUCO /PNQ)’ 5OE)(
`/.1 @*/Y -/20 &@ZY* =^g* .,,/’**********************************************************************************************2( 5
`
`/GSUCKO -ISKEVMUVSCM @SCEUPST AOFGS ,+ =PXGS @CLG(<HH 4PSTGQPXGS(
`Cck* Hd* //3)N;)/4,( =dbbxc Ie* Vi -, &;eg* .0( -553’ *******************************************************0
`
`/GSUCKO 0KIKUCM @GMGWKTKPO =SPFVEUT COF /GSUCKO =SPFVEUT /POUCKOKOI ?CNG COF
`9GUJPFT PH ATKOI ?CNG(
`Cck* Hd* //3)N;)2-3( =dbbxc Ie* Vi 2)3 &;j\* .-( .,,5’ *********************************************--( -/
`
`/PSOKOI 3MCTT BPSLT W) 5OU\M @SCFG /PNN\O(
`355 @*.Y -115 &@ZY* =^g* -542’**************************************************************************************************.
`
`3SGGODGSI W) 1UJKEPO 1OFP(?VSIGSZ’ 5OE)(
`5- @*/Y -14, &@ZY* =^g* -552’****************************************************************************************************2
`
`9GFKC >KIJUT @GEJT)’ 5OE) W) /CQKUCM <OG 2KO) /PSQ)(
`4,, @*/Y -/22 &@ZY* =^g* .,-1’**************************************************************************************************2
`
`?KGSSC /MVD W) 6CELTPO(
`4// @* Mjee* .Y -- &>*>*=* .,-.’ *********************************************************************************************0
`
`?UCOFCSF 4CWGOT =SPFT’ 5OE) W) 3GOEPS 5OFVT’ 5OC(
`453 @*.Y 1-- &@ZY* =^g* -55,’****************************************************************************************************0
`
`AOKWGSTCM /CNGSC /PSQ) W) ;8>.(
`/0, O*M* 030 &-51-’*******************************************************************************************************************.
`
`BCTJKOIUPO 9GU) -SGC @SCOTKU /PNN) W) 4PMKFCZ @PVST’ 5OE)(
`115 @*.Y 40- &>*=* =^g* -533’ ***************************************************************************************************0
`
`BKMMKCNTPO W) /KUSKY <OMKOG’ 88/(
`35. @*/Y -//5 &@ZY* =^g* .,-1’**************************************************************************************** QCTTKN
`
`BKTEPOTKO 3CT /P) k* 2GF) 1OGSIZ >GIVMCUPSZ /PNN [O)(
`314 @*.Y 225 &>*=* =^g* -541’ *************************************************************************************************-,
`
`^^
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`PUBLIC
`
`Statutes
`B[J[\[NZ
`
`1 O*M*=* p 3,1**********************************************************************************************************************************0
`5 U.S.C. § 705 ................................................................................................................................ ..4
`
`1 O*M*=* p 3,2&.’&?’ ************************************************************************************************************************.
`5 U.S.C. § 706(2)(E) ...................................................................................................................... ..2
`
`/1 O*M*=* p --.( q 2 *****************************************************************************************************************-( 1( 2
`35 U.S.C. (3‘ 112,116 ............................................................................................................... ..1,5,6
`
`iii
`^^^
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`=dbeaV^cVcih HVji^ajh Bndhjc\( CcX* VcY HVji^ajh Bndhjc\ ;bZg^XV( CcX* &XdaaZXi^kZan(
`
`uBndhjc\v’ gZheZXi[jaan hjWb^i i]^h Wg^Z[ deedh^c\ >^ZWdaYxh Gdi^dc [dg MiVn d[ LZbZY^Va
`
`IgYZgh JZcY^c\ ;eeZVa*
`
`8=CA>3D2C8>=
`
`N]Z ^ckZci^dc d[ O*M* JViZci 4(1./(./1 &ui]Z x./1 eViZci(v DR),,,-’ lVh V WgZV‘i]gdj\]
`
`^c i]Z Vgi* Ci egdk^YZY Vc ;NG l^i] V eVgi^XjaVg ZaZXigd)bZX]Vc^XVa Xdc[^\jgVi^dc i]Vi XdjaY
`
`VXXZei( egdXZhh( VcY YZedh^i V b^mZY WjcYaZ d[ XVh] VcY X]ZX‘h VcY ^cXajYZY ig^eVgi^iZ hZch^c\ id
`
`egZkZci dkZgaVee^c\ WVc‘cdiZh [gdb egd\gZhh^c\ i]gdj\] i]Z hnhiZb*
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc [dg V hiVn ^h egZb^hZY dc il^XZ)gZ_ZXiZY ^ciZgegZiVi^dch d[ ild x./1
`
`eViZci XaV^b a^b^iVi^dch6 uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv VcY uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidg*v BVk^c\ iZcYZgZY i]ZhZ
`
`^ciZgegZiVi^dch id DjY\Z M]Vl( VcY ]Vk^c\ i]Zb gZ_ZXiZY( VcY i]Zc iZcYZg^c\ i]Zb id i]Z
`
`=dbb^hh^dc( VcY ]Vk^c\ i]Zb gZ_ZXiZY( >^ZWdaY cdl egdedhZh i]Vi i]Z @ZYZgVa =^gXj^i b^\]i
`
`iV‘Z V Y^[[ZgZci k^Zl* >^ZWdaY ^h lgdc\* =dcigVgn id >^ZWdaYxh VhhZgi^dch( i]Z Vg\jbZcih bVYZ
`
`Wn >^ZWdaY ijgc eg^bVg^an dc l]Zi]Zg i]ZhZ iZgbh YZcdiZY higjXijgZ id dcZ d[ h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi
`
`V
`
`WVh^X [VXijVa YZiZgb^cVi^dc* Nd i]Z ZmiZci >^ZWdaY VeeZVah( ^ih VeeZVa l^aa i]jh aVg\Zan ijgc dc V
`
`eaZV id ]VkZ i]Z @ZYZgVa =^gXj^i dkZgijgc i]Z =dbb^hh^dcxh [VXijVa YZiZgb^cVi^dch Vh id V eZghdc
`
`d[ h‘^aaxh jcYZghiVcY^c\ VcY DjY\Z M]Vlxh VhhZhhbZci d[ l^icZhh XgZY^W^a^in* N]Z aZ\Va ^hhjZh
`
`^ckdakZ a^iiaZ bdgZ i]Vc Veea^XVi^dc d[ lZaa)hZiiaZY aVl( ^cXajY^c\ i]Z BKMMKCNTPO XVhZ
`
`Zbe]Vh^oZY i]gdj\]dji >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc* =dcigVgn id >^ZWdaYxh VhhZgi^dc( i]ZgZ ^h cd uY^[[^Xjai
`
`aZ\Va fjZhi^dcv ]ZgZ* BKMMKCNTPO ^bedhZY V XaZVg Zk^YZci^Vgn WjgYZc dc >^ZWdaY id gZWji V
`
`egZhjbei^dc i]Vi XZgiV^c gZfj^gZbZcih ^c /1 O*M*=* p --.( q 2 Yd 238 Veean ]ZgZ* DjY\Z M]Vl
`
`egdeZgan [djcY i]Vi >^ZWdaY [V^aZY id VhhZbWaZ i]Z gZXdgY Zk^YZcXZ cZZYZY id dkZgXdbZ i]Vi
`
`egZhjbei^dc* DjY\Z M]Vl ^chiZVY XgZY^iZY Bndhjc\xh ZmeZgi l^icZhh >g* BdlVgY l]d
`
`-
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`eV^chiV‘^c\an eadj\]ZY i]gdj\] i]Z Zk^YZci^Vgn gZXdgY( VhhZhhZY i]Z bZVc^c\ d[ i]Z XaV^b iZgbh(
`
`VcY YZbdchigViZY ^c[g^c\ZbZci VcY egVXi^XZ d[ i]Z VhhZgiZY XaV^bh* >g* BdlVgY cdi dcan gZa^ZY
`
`dc XdbeZaa^c\ YdXjbZcih( hdjgXZ XdYZ( VcY l^icZhh iZhi^bdcn Vh Zk^YZcXZ( Wji ]Z Vahd heZci
`
`bjai^eaZ YVnh iZhi^c\ VXXjhZY VcY YdbZhi^X egdYjXih id kZg^[n i]Z egVXi^XZ d[ i]Z VhhZgiZY XaV^bh*
`
`N]ZgZ[dgZ( DjY\Z M]Vl egdeZgan XgZY^iZY i]Z iZhi^bdcn d[ Bndhjc\xh ZmeZgi gZ\VgY^c\ i]Z
`
`uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv VcY uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv iZgbh Vh eVgi d[ i]Z C>xh hjWh^Y^Vgn XaV^b
`
`XdchigjXi^dc [VXi [^cY^c\* M]djaY >^ZWdaY VeeZVa( i]Z [VXijVa [^cY^c\h d[ DjY\Z M]Vl( ZcYdghZY
`
`Wn i]Z =dbb^hh^dc( l^aa gZXZ^kZ h^\c^[^XVci YZ[ZgZcXZ* ?GG’ G)I)( 1 O*M*=* p 3,2&.’&?’
`
`&egZhXg^W^c\ uhjWhiVci^Va Zk^YZcXZv Vh i]Z hiVcYVgY d[ _jY^X^Va gZk^Zl d[ VYb^c^higVi^kZ V\ZcXn
`
`[VXi [^cY^c\h’7 AOKWGSTCM /CNGSC /PSQ) W) ;8>.( /0, O*M* 030( 033 &-51-’ &YZhXg^W^c\ i]Z
`
`cVggdl hXdeZ d[ hjWhiVci^Va Zk^YZcXZ gZk^Zl7 cdi^c\ i]Vi V gZk^Zl^c\ Xdjgi l^aa cdi jcYd V
`
`V\ZcXnxh [VXijVa [^cY^c\ l]ZgZ i]Z gZaZkVci Zk^YZcXZ b^\]i aZVY V gZVhdcVWaZ b^cY id VXXZei i]Z
`
`V\ZcXnxh XdcXajh^dc’7 /PSOKOI 3MCTT BPSLT W) 5OU\M @SCFG /PNN\O( 355 @*.Y -115( -122 &@ZY*
`
`=^g* -542’ &Veean^c\ ;J; MZXi^dc 3,2 hjWhiVci^Va Zk^YZcXZ gZk^Zl ^c i]Z XdciZmi d[ CN= [VXi
`
`[^cY^c\h7 cdi^c\ i]Vi hjX] gZk^Zl ^h ucVggdlan a^b^iZYv’* N]jh( >^ZWdaYxh Vg\jbZcih gZ\VgY^c\
`
`i]Z bZg^ih [V^a id hjeedgi ^ih gZfjZhi [dg V hiVn d[ i]Z =dbb^hh^dcxh ^c_jcXi^dc*
`
`N]Z gZbV^cYZg d[ >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc ^h YZkdiZY id edgigVn^c\ ^ihZa[ Vh V YdbZhi^X Zci^in
`
`i]Vi ldjaY
`
`=dcigVgn id
`
`>^ZWdaYxh VhhZgi^dch
`
`VcY ^ih cdi idd hjWiaZ ^bea^XVi^dch >^ZWdaY VcY Bndhjc\ VgZ Wdi]
`
`bjai^cVi^dcVa XdgedgVi^dch l^i] h^\c^[^XVci deZgVi^dch ^c i]Z Oc^iZY MiViZh VcY VgdjcY i]Z ldgaY*
`
`CcYZZY( Bndhjc\xh h^\c^[^XVci O*M* deZgVi^dch VgZ gZVY^an VeeVgZci VcY( cdi hjgeg^h^c\an( aZY id
`
`DjY\Z M]Vlxh YZiZgb^cVi^dc i]Vi i]Z ZXdcdb^X YdbZhi^X ^cYjhign gZfj^gZbZci lVh hVi^h[^ZY* ?GG
`
`.
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`C> Vi /0-* GdgZdkZg( i]Z ]Vgb >^ZWdaY ldjaY VaaZ\ZYan hj[[Zg ^h Zci^gZan heZXjaVi^kZ* ?kZc [dg
`
`i]Z kV\jZ ]Vgb ^i YdZh VaaZ\Z( >^ZWdaY [V^ah id X^iZ hjeedgi ^c i]Z gZXdgY* QdghZ( >^ZWdaY
`
`cZ\aZXih id VYk^hZ i]Z =dbb^hh^dc i]Vi dc i]Z
`
`N]jh( >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc ^h YddbZY Wn ^ih [V^ajgZ &VcY VeeVgZci ^cVW^a^in’ id
`
`^YZci^[n Vcn eVgi^XjaVg ^ggZeVgVWaZ ]Vgb ^c VYY^i^dc id [V^a^c\ id ^YZci^[n Vcn uVYb^iiZYan Y^[[^Xjai
`
`aZ\Va fjZhi^dc*v FVhian( i]Z ejWa^X ^ciZgZhi ^c gZbZYn^c\ i]Z ^bedgiVi^dc d[ ^c[g^c\^c\ egdYjXih
`
`i]Vi k^daViZ hZXi^dc //3 ^h XaZVg VcY XdbeZah V YZc^Va d[ >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc id hiVn*
`
`8&
`
`?A>243DA0; 78BC>AG
`
`>^ZWdaYxh Vg\jbZci gZ\VgY^c\ i]Z ild iZgbh ^i cdl VaaZ\Zh VgZ XZcigVa id i]^h Zci^gZ
`
`^ckZhi^\Vi^dc dXXje^ZY Vaa d[ ild)eajh eV\Zh ^c ^ih cZVgan .,,)eV\Z edhi)]ZVg^c\ Wg^Z[*. N]ZhZ
`
`ild iZgbh lZgZ idhhZY ^c Vbdc\hi i]Z ‘^iX]Zc)h^c‘ d[ .3 XaV^b XdchigjXi^dc Y^hejiZh gV^hZY Wn
`
`>^ZWdaY( Vadc\ l^i] V bjai^ijYZ d[ di]Zg ^hhjZh egZhZciZY ^c ^ih edhi)]ZVg^c\ Wg^Z[^c\* DjY\Z
`
`DjY\Z M]Vl YZiZgb^cZY( [dg ZmVbeaZ( i]Vi Bndhjc\ ]Vh h^\c^[^XVci O*M* ^ckZhibZcih ^c6 &-’
`eaVci VcY Zfj^ebZci7 VcY &.’ ZbeadnbZci d[ aVWdg dg XVe^iVa* ?GG C> Vi /-1 &u=dbeaV^cVcih ]VkZ
`bVYZ VcY Xdci^cjZ id bV‘Z h^\c^[^XVci O*M* ^ckZhibZcih ^c eaVci VcY Zfj^ebZci VcY h^\c^[^XVci
`ZbeadnbZci d[ O*M* aVWdg VcY XVe^iVa*v’* Bndhjc\ ]Vh [VX^a^i^Zh ^c NZmVh( =Va^[dgc^V( VcY I]^d(
`Vh lZaa Vh hZgk^XZ eZghdccZa deZgVi^c\ ^c .5 hiViZh l^i]^c i]Z Oc^iZY MiViZh* ?GG C> Vi /-1* Cc
`.,-1 VadcZ( Bndhjc\ heZci dkZg
`Zbeadn^c\ O*M* aVWdg* ?GG C> Vi /-47 TGG CMTP
`=JR),,./= &HB; MA; MjbbVgn’* Bndhjc\xh O*M* ZbeadnZZh VgZ ^ckdakZY ^c i]Z [^c^h]^c\(
`iZX]c^XVa hjeedgi( gZeV^g( hd[ilVgZ hjeedgi( VcY [^ZaY hZgk^XZ d[ ^ih O*M*)WVhZY ;NGh* ?GG C> Vi
`/-4)..* ;cY Bndhjc\xh ZmiZch^kZ YdbZhi^X egZhZcXZ ^h \gdl^c\( Vh ZmZbea^[^ZY Wn ^ih
`^cXgZVh^c\ hVaZh id
`&=R),.32= &>Vc^Zah QM’ Vi K+; -.’ cZXZhh^iVi^c\ V cZl
`d[[^XZ ^c =]VgadiiZ id WZiiZg hjeedgi i]Z
`&=R),.32= &>Vc^Zah
`QM’ Vi K+; 5/’* ?GG CMTP ]iieh6++X]VgadiiZX]VbWZg*Xdb+cZlh+.,-3+,1+-2+
`X]VbWZg)cZlh+cVji^ajh)]ndhjc\)VbZg^XV)deZchcZl)X]VgadiiZ)d[[^XZ+*
`
`. ?GG >^ZWdaY JB< Vi 2)-. &dcZ hZXi^dc ajbe^c\ uX]ZX‘ hiVcYWn jc^iv id\Zi]Zg l^i] 1 di]Zg
`iZgbh’7 VcY Vi -4)-5 &Veegdm^bViZan dcZ eV\Z VYYgZhh^c\ uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv’*
`
`/
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`M]Vl gZ_ZXiZY ZVX] d[ >^ZWdaYxh Vg\jbZcih Wn Yd^c\ ZmVXian l]Vi i]Z =dbb^hh^dcxh
`
`;Yb^c^higVi^kZ FVl DjY\Zh VgZ X]Vg\ZY id Yd6 eZg[dgb^c\ V XVgZ[ja aZ\Va VcVanh^h( bV‘^c\
`
`YZiV^aZY [VXi [^cY^c\h( VcY VhijiZan VhhZhh^c\ l^icZhh XgZY^W^a^in* HZmi( >^ZWdaY gZigZViZY id
`
`Vg\j^c\ _jhi i]gZZ XaV^b a^b^iVi^dch ^c ^ih eZi^i^dc [dg gZk^Zl id i]Z =dbb^hh^dc* N]Z
`
`=dbb^hh^dc( ]dlZkZg( YZXa^cZY id [jgi]Zg VYYgZhh Vcn d[ i]dhZ i]gZZ ^hhjZh VcY( jai^bViZan(
`
`V[[^gbZY DjY\Z M]Vlxh gja^c\h* >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc cdl h^bean gZ\jg\^iViZh i]Z hVbZ VhhZgi^dch
`
`[dg ild d[ i]Z i]gZZ iZgbh >^ZWdaY egZk^djhan Vg\jZY id i]Z =dbb^hh^dc VcY adhi*
`
`88&
`
`5>DA%502C>A C4BC 5>A <>C8>=B C> BC0G ?4=38=6 0??40;
`
`MZXi^dc -,&Y’ d[ i]Z ;Yb^c^higVi^kZ JgdXZYjgZ ;Xi egdk^YZh i]Z =dbb^hh^dc Vji]dg^in id
`
`uedhiedcZ i]Z Z[[ZXi^kZ YViZ d[ VXi^dc iV‘Zc Wn ^i( eZcY^c\ _jY^X^Va gZk^Zlv ^[ ^i u[^cYh i]Vi _jhi^XZ
`
`hd gZfj^gZh*v 1 O*M*=* p 3,1* N]Z [djg)eVgi iZhi Vh hZi [dgi] Wn i]Z @ZYZgVa =^gXj^i [dg VhhZhh^c\
`
`l]Zi]Zg id hiVn V bViiZg eZcY^c\ VeeZVa ^h Vh [daadlh6
`
`&-’ l]Zi]Zg i]Z hiVn Veea^XVci ]Vh bVYZ V higdc\ h]dl^c\ i]Vi ]Z ^h
`a^‘Zan id hjXXZZY dc i]Z bZg^ih7 &.’ l]Zi]Zg i]Z Veea^XVci l^aa WZ
`^ggZeVgVWan ^c_jgZY VWhZci V hiVn7 &/’ l]Zi]Zg i]Z ^hhjVcXZ d[ i]Z
`hiVn l^aa hjWhiVci^Vaan ^c_jgZ i]Z di]Zg eVgi^Zh ^ciZgZhiZY ^c i]Z
`egdXZZY^c\7 VcY &0’ l]ZgZ i]Z ejWa^X ^ciZgZhi a^Zh*
`
`?UCOFCSF 4CWGOT =SPFT’ 5OE) W) 3GOEPS 5OFVT’ 5OC( 453 @*.Y 1--( 1-. &@ZY* =^g* -55,’7 TGG CMTP
`
`?KGSSC /MVD W) 6CELTPO( 4// @* Mjee* .Y --( /, &>*>*=* .,-.’ &cdi^c\ i]Vi i]Z hiVcYVgY [dg V hiVn
`
`Vi i]Z V\ZcXn aZkZa ^h ui]Z hVbZ Vh i]Z hiVcYVgY [dg V hiVn Vi i]Z _jY^X^Va aZkZa6 ZVX] ^h \dkZgcZY
`
`Wn i]Z [djg)eVgi egZa^b^cVgn ^c_jcXi^dc iZhi*v’* BdlZkZg( i]Z [^ghi egdc\ d[ i]Z 0)eVgi iZhi bVn
`
`Vahd WZ hVi^h[^ZY ^[ i]Z bdkVci ZhiVWa^h]Zh i]Vi i]Z =dbb^hh^dc ]Vh gjaZY dc uVc VYb^iiZYan
`
`Y^[[^Xjai aZ\Va fjZhi^dc*v /GSUCKO -ISKEVMUVSCM @SCEUPST AOFGS ,+ =PXGS @CLG(<HH 4PSTGQPXGS’
`
`Cck* Hd* //3)N;)/4,( =dbbxc Ie* Vi -, &;eg* .0( -553’ &EKUKOI BCTJKOIUPO 9GU) -SGC @SCOTKU
`
`/PNN) W) 4PMKFCZ @PVST’ 5OE)( 115 @*.Y 40-( 400)01 &>*=* =^g* -533’’*
`
`0
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`0&
`
`3841>;3 508;B C> 834=C85G 0= a03<8CC43;G 385582D;C
`;460; @D4BC8>=b
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc bjhi WZ YZc^ZY WZXVjhZ ^i [V^ah id XaZVg i]Z b^c^bVa i]gZh]daY d[ Vi aZVhi
`
`ZhiVWa^h]^c\ i]Vi i]Z =dbb^hh^dc ]Vh gjaZY jedc Vc uVYb^iiZYan Y^[[^Xjai aZ\Va fjZhi^dc*v BZgZ(
`
`>^ZWdaYxh X]VaaZc\Z Wd^ah Ydlc id V XdbeaV^ci i]Vi DjY\Z M]Vl XgZY^iZY i]Z [VXijVa iZhi^bdcn d[
`
`Bndhjc\xh ZmeZgi gVi]Zg i]Vc i]Z iZhi^bdcn egZhZciZY Wn >^ZWdaYxh ZmeZgi* N]jh( >^ZWdaYxh
`
`bdi^dc [V^ah id ^YZci^[n Vcn aZ\Va ^hhjZ( bjX] aZhh Vc uVYb^iiZYan Y^[[^Xjaiv dcZ*
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc cdiZh i]Vi ^c BKMMKCNTPO W) /KUSKY <OMKOG’ 88/’ 35. @*/Y -//5 &@ZY*
`
`=^g* .,-1’( i]Z @ZYZgVa =^gXj^i XaVg^[^ZY i]Z aZ\Va hiVcYVgY [dg VhhZhh^c\ l]Zi]Zg i]Z iZgbh d[ V
`
`eViZci h]djaY WZ ^ciZgegZiZY Vh ubZVch eajh [jcXi^dcv a^b^iVi^dch &K)G*( ^ciZgegZiZY VXXdgY^c\ id
`
`i]Z gZfj^gZbZcih d[ /1 O*M*=* p --.( q 2’* Jg^dg id BKMMKCNTPO( hdbZ @ZYZgVa =^gXj^i YZX^h^dch
`
`hiViZY i]Vi i]ZgZ lVh V uhigdc\ egZhjbei^dcv i]Vi ^[ i]Z iZgb ubZVchv lVh cdi jhZY ^c V XaV^b
`
`a^b^iVi^dc( i]Zc i]Z a^b^iVi^dc lVh cdi V bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc a^b^iVi^dc* BKMMKCNTPO XaVg^[^ZY i]Vi
`
`V eViZciZZxh YZX^h^dc id cdi jhZ i]Z iZgb ubZVchv gZhjaih ^c V gZWjiiVWaZ egZhjbei^dc &Vh deedhZY
`
`id V uhigdc\v gZWjiiVWaZ egZhjbei^dc’ i]Vi i]Z a^b^iVi^dc ^h hjW_ZXi id i]Z gjaZh d[ p --.( q 2*
`
`BKMMKCNTPO( 35. @* /Y Vi -/05 &uBZcXZ[dgi]( lZ l^aa Veean i]Z egZhjbei^dc Vh lZ ]VkZ YdcZ
`
`eg^dg id 8KIJUKOI BPSMF( l^i]dji gZfj^g^c\ Vcn ]Z^\]iZcZY Zk^YZci^Vgn h]dl^c\ VcY ZmegZhhan
`
`dkZggjaZ i]Z X]VgVXiZg^oVi^dc d[ i]Vi egZhjbei^dc Vh whigdc\*xv’*
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc VhhZgih i]Vi DjY\Z M]Vl VcY i]Z =dbb^hh^dc uVeeZVg id ]VkZ _jY\ZY
`
`i]Z XaV^bh jcYZg V egZ)BKMMKCNTPO hiVcYVgYv* <g* Vi 2* N]Vi hiViZbZci ^h cdi hjeedgiZY Wn i]Z
`
`gZXdgY* DjY\Z M]Vl ^c [VXi )/8+*( VcY +=8+27/;+0> 5938+*( i]Z BKMMKCNTPO hiVcYVgY* &TGG’ G)I*( C>
`
`Vi /4)/5 &uBKMMKCNTPO( ]dlZkZg( heZX^[^XVaan dkZggjaZY i]Z X]VgVXiZg^oVi^dc d[ i]Vi egZhjbei^dc
`
`Vh whigdc\(x i]Z hiVcYVgY hZi ^c 8KIJUKOI BPSMF* * * * BKMMKCNTPO ZmeaV^cZY i]Vi i]Z @ZYZgVa =^gXj^i
`
`1
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`l^aa Veean i]Z hiVcYVgY eg^dg id 8KIJUKOI BPSMF( ^*Z*( i]Z [V^ajgZ id jhZ i]Z ldgY wbZVchx XgZViZh V
`
`gZWjiiVWaZ egZhjbei^dc i]Vi p --.( eVgV* 2 YdZh cdi Veean* * * *v &^ciZgcVa fjdiVi^dch db^iiZY’’
`
`DjY\Z M]Vl Vahd ZmegZhhan gZXd\c^oZY i]Z Zk^YZci^Vgn WjgYZc >^ZWdaY WdgZ id gZWji i]Z
`
`egZhjbei^dc i]Vi p --.( q 2 YdZh cdi Veean6
`
`LZWjii^c\ V egZhjbei^dc V\V^chi bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc igZVibZci gZfj^gZh egdd[ i]Vi dcZ d[
`dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi ldjaY WZ jcVWaZ id jcYZghiVcY i]Z XaV^b ^c higjXijgVa iZgbh*v
`
`5F) DjY\Z M]Vl i]Zc heZX^[^XVaan Veea^ZY i]Z BKMMKCNTPO hiVcYVgY VcY bVYZ i]Z gZaZkVci [VXijVa
`
`[^cY^c\h gZ\VgY^c\ Vaa d[ i]Z Y^hejiZY XaV^b iZgbh( ^cXajY^c\ i]Z ild iZgbh cdl Vi ^hhjZ* ?GG C>
`
`Vi 00 VcY 25* N]jh( i]ZgZ ^h cd aZ\Va Zggdg Vi Vaa( bjX] aZhh i]Z uY^[[^Xjai aZ\Va fjZhi^dcv >^ZWdaY
`
`^begdeZgan XaV^bh*
`
`@daadl^c\ ^ih ^cVXXjgViZ Y^hXjhh^dc d[ BKMMKCNTPO( ^cXajY^c\ i]Z VaaZ\ZY [V^ajgZ id Veean
`
`^i id i]^h CckZhi^\Vi^dc( >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc \ZcZgVaan YZkdakZh ^cid V [VXijVaan ^ciZch^kZ XdbeaV^ci
`
`gZ\VgY^c\ i]Z Zk^YZcXZ DjY\Z M]Vl XgZY^iZY ^c Vgg^k^c\ Vi ]^h [VXijVa [^cY^c\h* <g* Vi 3)5 &X^i^c\
`
`VcY Xg^i^fj^c\ iZhi^bdcn VcY Zk^YZcXZ egZhZciZY Wn Bndhjc\ VcY ^ih iZX]c^XVa ZmeZgi’* <ji(
`
`cdi]^c\ ^c >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc gZbdiZan h]dlh V aVX‘ d[ hjWhiVci^Va Zk^YZcXZ id hjeedgi DjY\Z
`
`M]Vlxh [VXijVa [^cY^c\h gZ\VgY^c\ ]dl dcZ d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi( ^c i]Z XdciZmi d[ i]Z
`
`^cig^ch^X VcY Zmig^ch^X Zk^YZcXZ( ldjaY jcYZghiVcY i]Vi i]Z XaV^bh XdccdiZ hj[[^X^Zcian YZ[^c^iZ
`
`higjXijgZ [dg eZg[dgb^c\ i]Z [jcXi^dc ^c i]Z XaV^b* ?GG BKMMKCNTPO( 35. @*/Y Vi -/05 &EKUKOI
`
`3SGGODGSI W) 1UJKEPO 1OFP(?VSIGSZ’ 5OE)( 5- @*/Y -14,( -140 &@ZY* =^g* -552’’7 9GFKC >KIJUT
`
`@GEJT)’ 5OE) W) /CQKUCM <OG 2KO) /PSQ)( 4,, @*/Y -/22 &@ZY* =^g* .,-1’’* CcYZZY( YjZ id i]Z
`
`BKMMKCNTPO egZhjbei^dc V\V^chi bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc igZVibZci( ^i lVh >^ZWdaYxh dWa^\Vi^dc id
`
`XdbZ [dgi] l^i] egZedcYZgVci Zk^YZcXZ ,36 bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc igZVibZci* -QGY’ 5OE) W) >CSKUCO
`
`/PNQ)’ 5OE)( /.1 @*/Y -/20( -/3. &@ZY* =^g* .,,/’* <ji >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc *3+7 238 /2)09*+ ’
`
`2
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`7/2-0+ )/8’8/32 83 /87 3<2 +=4+68 36 ’2> 3, /87 3<2 +;/*+2)+ [dg Z^i]Zg d[ i]Z iZgbh VWdji l]^X] ^i
`
`cdl XdbeaV^ch*
`
`R&
`
`9\MPN BQJ^cZ JUM [QN 2VTTRZZRVUcZ 5JL[\JS 5RUMRUPZ ANPJYMRUP
`a2QNX\N B[JUMK‘ DUR[b 0YN B\WWVY[NM K‘ B\KZ[JU[RJS 4]RMNULN
`
`>^ZWdaYxh Wg^Z[ \ZcZgVaan ]^\]a^\]ih ]dl i]Z =dbb^hh^dcxh YZiZgb^cVi^dc gZ\VgY^c\
`
`uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv gZhih dc l]Zi]Zg >^ZWdaY iZcYZgZY hj[[^X^Zci Zk^YZcXZ id gZWji i]Z
`
`BKMMKCNTPO egZhjbei^dc* SZi( gVi]Zg i]Vc X^i^c\ id Zk^YZcXZ d[ ^ih dlc( >^ZWdaYxh Wg^Z[ ViiZbeih
`
`id [a^e i]Z Zk^YZci^Vgn WjgYZc VcY Vg\jZh i]Vi i]ZgZ lVh hdbZ \Ve ^c Bndhjc\xh egdd[ i]Vi h]djaY
`
`hdbZ]dl aZVY id bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc igZVibZci [dg i]Z uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv iZgb* <ji( Vh
`
`DjY\Z M]Vl egdeZgan YZiZgb^cZY( V eZghdc d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi ldjaY cdi k^Zl i]Z
`
`uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv Vh Vc ^chiVcXZ d[ [jcXi^dcVa XaV^b^c\( Wji ldjaY jcYZghiVcY ^i id YZcdiZ
`
`heZX^[^X higjXijgZ* C> Vi 25 &u; eZghdc d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi ldjaY jcYZghiVcY i]Vi V
`
`higjXijgZ ^c Vc ;NG i]Vi iZbedgVg^an ]daYh X]ZX‘h eZcY^c\ i]Z XjhidbZg Xdc[^gb^c\ i]Z YZedh^i
`
`^h i]Z X]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^i* Cc \ZcZgVa( V X]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^i ^h i]Z ZhXgdl i]Vi iZbedgVg^an ]daYh
`
`i]Z X]ZX‘h*v’* DjY\Z M]Vlxh [VXijVa YZiZgb^cVi^dc lVh Vbean hjeedgiZY Wn i]Z gZXdgY( ^cXajY^c\
`
`i]Z iZhi^bdcn d[ >g* BdlVgY* BZ YZhXg^WZY ]dl i]Z e]gVhZ uV X]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv ldjaY
`
`cZXZhhVg^an ]VkZ V higjXijgVa bZVc^c\ id hjX] V eZghdc( VcY ldjaY gZ[Zg id i]Z e]nh^XVa edgi^dc d[
`
`V XVh])VcY)X]ZX‘ YZedh^i^c\ bdYjaZ i]Vi ^h Xdbeg^hZY d[ lZaa)‘cdlc XdbedcZcih
`
`=R).30= &BdlVgY
`
`QM’ Vi K+; -45* N]Z XaV^b Vahd Xdc[Zgh VYY^i^dcVa higjXijgZ ^c i]Z [dgb d[ YZhXg^W^c\ ]dl i]Z
`
`uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv bjhi WZ ueaVXZY ^c i]Z bV^c igVch[Zg eVi] WZilZZc i]Z [^ghi \ViZ VcY i]Z
`
`hZXdcY \ViZ*v DR),,,- &x./1 eViZci’( Xda* -,( ach* 1, 117 =>R).-.2* N]Z gZXdgY ^cXajYZY VbeaZ
`
`Zk^YZcXZ i]Vi V eZghdc d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi ldjaY jcYZghiVcY i]Z heZX^[^X higjXijgZ YZcdiZY
`
`3
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`Wn V uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^iv ^c i]Z Vgi( l]^X] i]Z C> egdeZgan gZa^ZY dc* ?GG C> Vi 25 &X^i^c\ =R)
`
`,.30= &BdlVgY QM’ Vi K+; -41 42( -45’* HdiVWan( >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc [V^ah id X^iZ Vcn Zk^YZcXZ
`
`id i]Z XdcigVgn( [gdb ^ih dlc ZmeZgi dg Vcn di]Zg hdjgXZ( VcY i]jh XVccdi h]dl i]Vi i]Z ;FDxh
`
`[^cY^c\ ^h jchjeedgiZY Wn hjWhiVci^Va Zk^YZcXZ ^c i]Z gZXdgY*
`
`RR&
`
`9\MPN BQJ^cZ JUM [QN 2VTTRZZRVUcZ 5JL[\JS 5RUMRUPZ ANSJ[NM [V a1\UMSN
`BNWJYJ[VYb 0YN B\WWVY[NM K‘ B\KZ[JU[RJS 4]RMNULN
`
`M^b^aVgan( i]Z Vg\jbZcih ^c >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc XdcXZgc^c\ uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv VgZ aVg\Zan
`
`Vc jceZghjVh^kZ gZYjm d[ [V^aZY Vg\jbZcih >^ZWdaY egZhZciZY [dg uX]ZfjZ hiVcYWn jc^i*v ;\V^c(
`
`>^ZWdaY XdbeaV^ch i]Vi DjY\Z M]Vl gZ_ZXiZY >^ZWdaYxh eaZV [dg bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc igZVibZci d[
`
`i]Z iZgb7 V\V^c( >^ZWdaY \^kZh h]dgi h]g^[i id i]Z BKMMKCNTPO egZhjbei^dc V\V^chi bZVch)eajh)
`
`[jcXi^dc igZVibZci7 VcY V\V^c( >^ZWdaY lg^iZh Vh ^[ ^i lZgZ i]Z eViZciZZ &Vh deedhZY id i]Z VaaZ\ZY
`
`^c[g^c\Zg l]d ]VY i]Z WjgYZc d[ egdd[ dc i]^h bViiZg’* GdgZdkZg( >^ZWdaYxh Wg^Z[ Vh‘h i]Z
`
`=dbb^hh^dc id jcYd [VXijVa [^cY^c\h d[ DjY\Z M]Vl i]Vi VgZ XaZVgan hjeedgiZY Wn hjWhiVci^Va
`
`Zk^YZcXZ ^c i]Z gZXdgY* N]Z =dbb^hh^dc h]djaY( i]ZgZ[dgZ( gZ_ZXi >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc gZ\VgY^c\
`
`i]^h ^hhjZ [dg bVcn d[ i]Z hVbZ gZVhdch ZmeaV^cZY VWdkZ*
`
`DjY\Z M]Vl egdeZgan [djcY( WVhZY dc i]Z iZhi^bdcn d[ Bndhjc\xh ZmeZgi >g* BdlVgY(
`
`i]Vi V eZghdc d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ldjaY jcYZghiVcY i]Z iZgb uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv id YZcdiZ heZX^[^X(
`
`‘cdlc higjXijgZ
`
`cdi( Vh >^ZWdaY XaV^bh( V \ZcZg^X gZ[ZgZcXZ id V [jcXi^dc* ;h i]Z C> egdeZgan
`
`cdiZY( ui]Z hZeVgVi^dc d[ bZY^V ^h V lZaa)ZhiVWa^h]ZY iZX]c^fjZ( VcY WjcYaZ hZeVgVidgh VgZ jhZY ^c
`
`bVcn ^cYjhig^Zh id eZg[dgb i]Z Xdbbdc [jcXi^dc d[ hZeVgVi^c\ ^cY^k^YjVa h]ZZih [gdb V hiVX‘ d[
`
`h]ZZih*v C> Vi 00 &X^i^c\ =R),.30= &BdlVgY QM’ Vi K+; 51’* @dg i]ZhZ gZVhdch( VcY Vh [jgi]Zg
`
`Y^hXjhhZY WZadl( i]Z DjY\Z M]Vl egdeZgan gZ_ZXiZY >^ZWdaYxh Vg\jbZci i]Vi uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv
`
`h]djaY gZXZ^kZ bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc igZVibZci*
`
`4
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc ^\cdgZh i]Vi( dcXZ V\V^c( ^i lVh >^ZWdaY l]d ]VY i]Z WjgYZc id
`
`YZbdchigViZ Wn egZedcYZgVci Zk^YZcXZ i]Vi V eZghdc d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ldjaY WZ jcVWaZ id Y^hXZgc
`
`cZXZhhVgn higjXijgZ ^c i]Z XaV^b( VcY i]Vi( i]ZgZ[dgZ( bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc igZVibZci ldjaY WZ
`
`lVggVciZY* ?GG’ G)I)( -QGY 5OE)( /.1 @*/Y Vi -/3.* <ZXVjhZ >^ZWdaY [V^aZY id bV‘Z hjX] V
`
`h]dl^c\( DjY\Z M]Vl egdeZgan [djcY i]Vi i]^h a^b^iVi^dc bjhi WZ XdchigjZY ^c V higjXijgVa
`
`[Vh]^dc* HdcZ d[ i]Z VhhZgi^dch bVYZ Wn >^ZWdaY h]dl i]Vi DjY\Z M]Vlxh [^cY^c\h VgZ cdi
`
`hjeedgiZY Wn hjWhiVci^Va Zk^YZcXZ* IcXZ V\V^c( >^ZWdaY [V^ah id X^iZ Vcn iZhi^bdcn d[ ^ih dlc
`
`ZmeZgi( ^chiZVY gZan^c\ dc Z[[dgih id uX]^e VlVnv Vi i]Z egdd[ [gdb Bndhjc\xh ZmeZgi VcY i]Z
`
`eViZci* >^ZWdaY( i]jh( Xdci^cjZh ^ih b^hiV‘Zc VeegdVX] d[ ^ckZgi^c\ i]Z BKMMKCNTPO egZhjbei^dc(
`
`jcYZg l]^X] >^ZWdaY WZVgh i]Z XaZVg WjgYZc d[ egdd[* ;h DjY\Z M]Vl egdeZgan [djcY( >g*
`
`BdlVgYxh iZhi^bdcn YZhXg^WZY ]dl uV WjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv ldjaY ]VkZ V higjXijgVa bZVc^c\ id V
`
`eZghdc d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi( VcY ldjaY gZ[Zg id i]Z e]nh^XVa edgi^dc d[ V XVh])VcY)X]ZX‘
`
`YZedh^i^c\ bdYjaZ i]Vi ^h Xdbeg^hZY d[ lZaa)‘cdlc XdbedcZcih ^c i]Z Vgi i]V
`
`=R),.30= &BdlVgY QM’ Vi K+; 53 54* N]Z XaV^b Vahd
`
`Xdc[Zgh VYY^i^dcVa higjXijgZ ^c i]Z [dgb d[ YZhXg^W^c\ ]dl i]Z uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv ^ciZgVXih l^i]
`
`di]Zg XaV^bZY ZaZbZcih* 5F* =aV^b - Zbe]Vh^oZh i]Vi i]Z WjcYaZ hZeVgVidg bjhi WZ XdjeaZY id i]Z
`
`WjcYaZ ^chZgi^dc jc^i( i]jh gZfj^g^c\ lZaa)‘cdlc XdbedcZcih id ^ciZg[VXZ l^i] i]Z edgi^dc d[ i]Z
`
`XVh])VcY)X]ZX‘ YZedh^i^c\ bdYjaZ i]Vi ]VcYaZh WjcYaZ ^chZgi^dc* @jgi]Zg( Vh VagZVYn Y^hXjhhZY(
`
`WjcYaZ hZeVgVi^c\ ^h V lZaa)ZhiVWa^h]ZY iZX]c^fjZ ^c bVcn Veea^XVi^dch( VcY
`
`;cY i]dj\] >^ZWdaY ViiZbeih id ^\cdgZ i]^h iZhi^bdcn( ^ih ZmeZgi >g* Mijg\Zh ’*1/88+*
`
`i]Vi id dcZ h‘^aaZY ^c i]Z Vgi( i]Z iZgb uhZeVgVidgv &Vh ^c( uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv’ XaZVgan YZcdiZh V
`
`5
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`heZX^[^X XdbedcZci( i]jh XdcigVY^Xi^c\ >^ZWdaYxh Vg\jbZci i]Vi i]Z iZgb ldjaY cdi ]VkZ
`
`higjXijgVa bZVc^c\ id dcZ d[ dgY^cVgn h‘^aa ^c i]Z Vgi6
`
`Bg\* Ng* &Mijg\Zh’ 1006- -,* >^ZWdaY ]Vh egZk^djhan ViiZbeiZY id Y^hiVcXZ ^ihZa[ [gdb i]^h(
`
`jg\^c\ i]Vi >g* Mijg\Zh lVh dcan hVn^c\ i]Vi i]Z ldgY uhZeVgVidgv YZcdiZY higjXijgZ ^c i]Z
`
`XdciZmi d[ V iZX]c^XVa bVcjVa( cdi ^c i]Z XdciZmi d[ i]Z x./1 eViZci* >^ZWdaY J@L Vi .3 c*1( .4
`
`c*2* <ji i]Vi ^h Vahd gZaZkVci* C[ V eZghdc d[ h‘^aa >^ZWdaYxh dlc ZmeZgi
`
`jcYZghiddY
`
`uhZeVgVidgv id YZcdiZ higjXijgZ ^c i]Z \ZcZgVa( cdc)eViZci XdciZmi d[ ;NGh( i]Zc i]Z iZgb Vahd
`
`YZcdiZh higjXijgZ ^c i]Z XdciZmi d[ V eViZci YZhXg^W^c\ VcY XaV^b^c\ Vc VjidbVi^X YZedh^i^c\
`
`VeeVgVijh* >g* BdlVgYxh iZhi^bdcn( X^iZY Wn i]Z C>( XaZVgan YZhXg^WZY l]Vi i]Z iZgb bZVch( VcY
`
`>g* BdlVgYxh YZ[^c^i^dc lVh Xdch^hiZci l^i] ]dl >g* Mijg\Zh Veea^ZY ^i* ?GG =R),.30= &BdlVgY
`
`QM’ Vi K+; 54 &YZhXg^W^c\ ]dl V h‘^aaZY Vgi^hVc ldjaY jcYZghiVcY i]Z iZgb id bZVc ui]Z
`
`e]nh^XVa edgi^dc d[ V XVh])VcY)X]ZX‘ YZedh^i^c\ bdYjaZ i]Vi ^h XdbW^cZY l^i] lZaa)‘cdlc
`
`XdbedcZcih(
`
`v’* N]^h
`
`[jgi]Zg higZc\i]Zch i]Z hjWhiVci^Va Zk^YZcXZ hjeedgi^c\ DjY\Z M]Vlxh [^cY^c\ i]Vi >^ZWdaY [V^aZY
`
`id egZhZci hj[[^X^Zci Zk^YZcXZ id gZWji i]Z egZhjbei^dc V\V^chi Xdchigj^c\ uWjcYaZ hZeVgVidgv id
`
`WZ V bZVch)eajh)[jcXi^dc iZgb* C> Vi 00*
`
`-,
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`1&
`
`3841>;3cB 0;;4643 70A< 8B B?42D;0C8E4
`
`N]Z =dbb^hh^dc ]Vh ZmeaV^cZY i]Z gZfj^gZY h]dl^c\ d[ ]Vgb jcYZg i]Z hZXdcY eVgi d[
`
`i]Z [djg)eVgi iZhi Vh [daadlh6
`
`?hiVWa^h]^c\ ^ggZeVgVWaZ ]Vgb hj[[^X^Zci id lVggVci V hiVn gZfj^gZh Vc ^c_jgn i]Vi ^h "Wdi]
`XZgiV^c VcY \gZVi7 ^i bjhi WZ VXijVa VcY cdi i]ZdgZi^XVa*" BKTEPOTKO 3CT /P) k* 2GF)
`1OGSIZ >GIVMCUPSZ /PNN &O)’ 314 @*.Y 225( 230 &>*=* =^g* -541’* Cc VcVano^c\
`^ggZeVgVWaZ ]Vgb( "TWUVgZ VaaZ\Vi^dch d[ l]Vi ^h a^‘Zan id dXXjg VgZ d[ cd kVajZ h^cXZ i]Z
`Xdjgi bjhi YZX^YZ l]Zi]Zg i]Z ]Vgb l^aa KO HCEU dXXjg*" 5F) Vi 230* Nd hjXXZZY( i]ZgZ[dgZ(
`LZhedcYZcih bjhi egdk^YZ "egdd[ ^cY^XVi^c\ i]Vi i]Z ]Vgb ^h XZgiV^c id dXXjg ^c i]Z cZVg
`[jijgZ*" 5F)
`
`/GSUCKO 0KIKUCM @GMGWKTKPO =SPFVEUT COF /GSUCKO =SPFVEUT /POUCKOKOI ?CNG COF 9GUJPFT PH
`
`ATKOI ?CNG’ Cck* Hd* //3)N;)2-3( =dbb%c Ie* Vi 2)3 &;j\* .-( .,,5’* >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc [Vaah
`
`[Vg h]dgi d[ i]Z gZfj^h^iZ egdd[ d[ XdcXgZiZ ^ggZeVgVWaZ ]Vgb*
`
`>^ZWdaY VhhZgih i]Vi ^i ]Vh
`
`* <g* Vi
`
`5*
`
`id i]Z ejWa^X6
`
`;ai]dj\] lZ VgZ eZi^i^dc^c\ i]Z CciZgcVi^dcVa NgVYZ =dbb^hh^dc &CN=’ id gZk^Zl
`i]Z GVgX] -/ ^c^i^Va YZiZgb^cVi^dc( /8 .’7 23 (+’6/2- 32 +=/78/2- 463*9)87 ^c i]Z
`bVg‘Zi dg [jijgZ egdYjXih egdk^YZY Wn >^ZWdaY H^mYdg[*
`
`]iie6++lll*egcZlhl^gZ*Xdb+cZlh)gZaZVhZh+Y^ZWdaY)c^mYdg[)hjXXZhh[jaan)YZ[ZVih)
`
`gZiVa^VidgnXaV^bh)Xdci^cjZh)ejghj^i)d[)eViZci)^c[g^c\ZbZci)XVhZ)V\V^chi)‘dgZV)WVhZY)cVji^ajh)
`
`]ndhjc\/,,0.1.,3*]iba &Zbe]Vh^h VYYZY’ &ejWa^X hiViZbZci [gdb >^ZWdaYxh hZc^dg k^XZ
`
`egZh^YZci( X]^Z[ aZ\Va d[[^XZg( VcY XdgedgViZ hZXgZiVgn DdcVi]Vc FZ^‘Zc( gZaZVhZY V[iZg DjY\Z M]Vl
`
`--
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`^hhjZY ]^h [^cVa ^c^i^Va YZiZgb^cVi^dc ^c i]^h CckZhi^\Vi^dc’* N]jh( ^i ldjaY VeeZVg i]Vi >^ZWdaY ^h
`
`WZ^c\ aZhh i]Vc [dgi]g^\]i l^i] Z^i]Zg i]Z ejWa^X dg l^i] i]Z =dbb^hh^dc*
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc Vahd ^\cdgZh Vcn edhh^W^a^in d[ Vkd^Y^c\ i]Z ^beVXi d[ i]Z ZmXajh^dc
`
`dgYZg
`
`Cc Vcn ZkZci(
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc bjhi WZ YZc^ZY [dg [V^a^c\ id ^YZci^[n Vcn heZX^[^X ^ggZeVgVWaZ ]Vgb i]Vi ^h
`
`XZgiV^c id dXXjg( bjX] aZhh egdk^YZ egdd[ d[ Vcn hjX] ]Vgb*
`
`2&
`
`7G>BD=6 F>D;3 14 70A<43 1G BC0G8=6 C74 8=9D=2C8>=
`
`Bndhjc\ ]Vh ZmiZch^kZ YdbZhi^X [VX^a^i^Zh VcY h^\c^[^XVci ZbeadnbZci d[ O*M* aVWdg VcY
`
`XVe^iVa( ^cXajY^c\ ^c NZmVh( =Va^[dgc^V( VcY I]^d( Vh lZaa Vh hZgk^XZ eZghdccZa deZgVi^c\ ^c .5
`
`hiViZh l^i]^c i]Z Oc^iZY MiViZh* ?GG C> Vi /-1* MiVn^c\ i]Z ZmXajh^dc dgYZg ldjaY Vaadl >^ZWdaY
`
`id Xdci^cjZ id ^c[g^c\Z i]Z x./1 eViZci l^i] ^bejc^in( jc[V^gan XdbeZiZ Wn jh^c\ Bndhjc\xh dlc
`
`iZX]cdad\n( VcY( i]jh( ]Vgb Bndhjc\xh Z[[dgi id Xdci^cjZ Wj^aY^c\ VcY ZmeVcY^c\ ^ih hjWhiVci^Va
`
`YdbZhi^X deZgVi^dch ^c i]Z Oc^iZY MiViZh* M^bean eji( ^c i]^h ^ckZhi^\Vi^dc Bndhjc\
`
`YZbdchigViZY i]Vi ^i lVh Zci^iaZY id gZa^Z[ jcYZg hZXi^dc //3 WZXVjhZ >^ZWdaY lVh ^bedgi^c\
`
`egdYjXih i]Vi Xdcig^WjiZ id i]Z ^c[g^c\ZbZci d[ i]Z w./1 eViZci VcY cdi]^c\ ^c >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc
`
`ZhiVWa^h]Zh i]Vi ^ih ^ciZgZhih h]djaY WZ [VkdgZY dkZg i]dhZ d[ Bndhjc\*
`
`-.
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`3&
`
`C74 ?D1;82 8=C4A4BC 3>4B =>C BD??>AC 0 BC0G
`
`>^ZWdaYxh Zci^gZ
`
`*/ ;h YZiV^aZY VWdkZ( cdi dcan ^h i]ZgZ cd hjeedgi ^c
`
`i]Z gZXdgY id h]dl i]Vi >^ZWdaY ldjaY VXijVaan hj[[Zg Vcn heZX^[^X ]Vgb( ^ih Zci^gZ Vg\jbZci id
`
`i]^h =dbb^hh^dc gZ\VgY^c\ ]dl ^i ldjaY hj[[Zg ^h [aVian XdcigVY^XiZY Wn l]Vi >^ZWdaYxh dlc
`
`d[[^X^Vah ]VkZ egdXaV^bZY id i]Z ejWa^X
`
`M^b^aVgan( >^ZWdaYxh Z[[dgi
`
`id bVa^\c Bndhjc\ Vh hdaZan WZ^c\ V [dgZ^\c XdbeVcn ^h Vi dYYh l^i] i]Z gZXdgY Vh lZaa Vh i]Z
`
`ZmiZch^kZ YZiV^aZY [^cY^c\h bVYZ Wn DjY\Z M]Vl i]Vi Bndhjc\ ]Vh ZhiVWa^h]ZY V hjWhiVci^Va
`
`YdbZhi^X ^cYjhign( ^cXajY^c\ ZmiZch^kZ [VX^a^i^Zh VcY ZbeadnZZh adXViZY ^c NZmVh*
`
`FVhian( i]^h =dbb^hh^dc ]Vh bVYZ XaZVg i]Vi ui]Z ejWa^X ^ciZgZhi HCWPST i]Z egdiZXi^dc d[
`
`^ciZaaZXijVa egdeZginrv ?GG /GSUCKO 0KIKUCM @GMGWKTKPO =SPFVEUT COF /GSUCKO =SPFVEUT
`
`/POUCKOKOI ?CNG COF 9GUJPFT PH ATKOI ?CNG’ Cck* Hd* //3)N;)2-3( =dbbxc Ie* Vi 5 &;j\*
`
`.-( .,,5’ &Vahd ZmeaV^c^c\ i]Vi uwTJUgdiZXi^dc d[ ^ciZaaZXijVa egdeZgin g^\]ih ^c i]Z Oc^iZY MiViZh
`
`egdk^YZh [dgZ^\c VcY YdbZhi^X Wjh^cZhhZh Va^‘Z l^i] V Xa^bViZ d[ egZY^XiVW^a^in i]Vi [dhiZgh
`
`^ckZhibZci( ^ccdkVi^dc( VcY i]Z ZmX]Vc\Z d[ iZX]cdad\n VcY VhhdX^ViZY ^ciZaaZXijVa egdeZgin
`
`g^\]ih*xv’* N]jh( ]ZgZ( i]Z ejWa^X ^ciZgZhi ^c gZbZYn^c\ i]Z ^bedgiVi^dc d[ ^c[g^c\^c\ egdYjXih i]Vi
`
`k^daViZ hZXi^dc //3 ^h XaZVg VcY XdbeZah V YZc^Va d[ >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc id hiVn*
`
`/ >^ZWdaY igjbeZih V aZiiZg hjWb^iiZY Wn XZgiV^c =dc\gZhh^dcVa gZegZhZciVi^kZh [gdb Hdgi]
`=Vgda^cV( nZi cdl]ZgZ bZci^dch i]Z aZiiZgh hjWb^iiZY Wn [djg =dc\gZhh^dcVa gZegZhZciVi^kZh [gdb
`NZmVh hjeedgi^kZ d[ Bndhjc\ VcY i]Z ^hhjVcXZ d[ Vc ZmXajh^dc dgYZg Vh gZXdbbZcYZY Wn DjY\Z
`M]Vl* FZiiZg [gdb LZegZhZciVi^kZ GVgX]Vci &[^aZY Djan -3( .,-3’( ?>CM Hd* 2-3/037 FZiiZg
`[gdb LZegZhZciVi^kZ Q^aa^Vbh &[^aZY dc Djan --( .,-3’( ?>CM Hd* 2-24427 FZiiZg [gdb
`LZegZhZciVi^kZ LViXa^[[Z &[^aZY dc Djan --( .,-3’( ?>CM Hd* 2-244.7 FZiiZg [gdb LZegZhZciVi^kZ
`MZhh^dch &[^aZY dc Djan --( .,-3’( ?>CM Hd* 2-24.,*
`
`-/
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`2>=2;DB8>=
`
`>^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc aVX‘h Vcn bZg^i6 &^’ ^i [V^ah id ^YZci^[n Vcn uVYb^iiZYan Y^[[^Xjai aZ\Va
`
`fjZhi^dcv7 &^^’ ^i [V^ah id ^YZci^[n Vcn ^ggZeVgVWaZ ]Vgb i]Vi ^h XZgiV^c id dXXjg
`
`^i egZhZcih V Y^hXjhh^dc d[ i]Z ejWa^X ^ciZgZhi ldZ[jaan aVX‘^c\ ^c hjWhiVcXZ* N]jh( Bndhjc\
`
`gZheZXi[jaan gZfjZhih i]Vi >^ZWdaYxh bdi^dc id hiVn WZ YZc^ZY*
`
`VcY &^^^’
`
`>ViZY6 Djan .3( .,-3
`
`LZheZXi[jaan hjWb^iiZY(
`
`@CMB $ LC=B;L>MIH J*=*
`
`*T* 7GWKO /) BJGGMGS
`G^X]VZa D* GXEZdc
`N^bdi]n Q* L^[[Z
`EZk^c =* Q]ZZaZg
`DdhZe] P* =daV^Vcc^
`N]dbVh M* @jhXd
`@CMB $ LC=B;L>MIH J*=*
`N]Z GXJ]Zghdc <j^aY^c\
`5,- -1i] MigZZi( H*Q*( 3i] @addg
`QVh]^c\idc( >= .,,,1
`NZa6 &.,.’ 34/)1,3,
`@Vm6 &.,.’ 34/).//-
`
`/PVOTGM HPS /PNQMCKOCOUT ;CVUKMVT 4ZPTVOI
`5OE) COF ;CVUKMVT 4ZPTVOI -NGSKEC 5OE)
`
`-0
`
`

`

`24AC85820C4 >5 B4AE824
`
`C ]ZgZWn XZgi^[n i]Vi igjZ VcY XdggZXi Xden d[ i]Z [dgZ\d^c\ YdXjbZci( >??>B8C8>= C>
`3841>;3cB <>C8>= 5>A BC0G >5 A4<4380; >A34AB ?4=38=6 0??40;$ ]Vh
`WZZc hZgkZY dc i]^h .3i] YVn d[ Djan( .,-3( dc i]Z [daadl^c\6
`
`N]Z BdcdgVWaZ F^hV L* <Vgidc
`MZXgZiVgn
`D&B& 8U[NYUJ[RVUJS CYJMN 2VTTRZZRVU
`1,, ? MigZZi( M*Q*
`QVh]^c\idc( >*=* .,0/2
`
`N]Z BdcdgVWaZ >Vk^Y J* M]Vl
`;Yb^c^higVi^kZ FVl DjY\Z
`D&B& 8U[NYUJ[RVUJS CYJMN 2VTTRZZRVU
`1,, ? MigZZi( M*Q*
`QVh]^c\idc( >*=* .,0/2
`
`JVig^X^V =]dl
`;iidgcZn ;Yk^hdg
`D&B& 8U[NYUJ[RVUJS CYJMN 2VTTRZZRVU
`1,, ? MigZZi( M*Q*
`QVh]^c\idc( >*=* .,0/2
`eVig^X^V*X]dl9jh^iX*\dk
`
`;YVb >* MlV^c
`;FMNIH $ <CL> FFJ
`51, @ MigZZi( HQ
`QVh]^c\idc( >= .,,,0)-0,0
`NZaZe]dcZ6 &.,.’)./5)//,,
`@VXh^b^aZ6 &.,.’ 210)040.
`>^ZWdaY*CN=9Vahidc*Xdb
`
`/PVOTGM HPS >GTQPOFGOUT 0KGDPMF’
`5OEPSQPSCUGF COF 0KGDPMF ?GMH ?GSWKEG
`?ZTUGNT
`
`ERJ 5RYZ[ 2SJZZ <JRS
`
`ERJ 7JUM 3NSR]NY‘
`
`ERJ 5NMNYJS 4_WYNZZ
`
`ERJ 4SNL[YVURL 5RSRUP
`
`ERJ 5RYZ[ 2SJZZ <JRS
`
`ERJ 7JUM 3NSR]NY‘
`
`ERJ 5NMNYJS 4_WYNZZ
`
`ERJ 4SNL[YVURL 5RSRUP
`
`ERJ 5RYZ[ 2SJZZ <JRS
`
`ERJ 7JUM 3NSR]NY‘
`
`ERJ 5NMNYJS 4_WYNZZ
`
`ERJ 4SNL[YVURL <JRS
`
`ERJ 5RYZ[ 2SJZZ <JRS
`
`ERJ 7JUM 3NSR]NY‘
`
`ERJ 5NMNYJS 4_WYNZZ
`
`ERJ 4SNL[YVURL <JRS
`
`*T* 1ELRVCMZO 4GFIGT
`
`

`

`PUBLIC
`
`CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
`
`I hereby certify that true and correct copy of the foregoing document, OPPOSITION TO
`
`DIEBOLD’S MOTION FOR STAY OF REMEDIAL ORDERS PENDING APPEAL, has
`been served on this 7th day of August, 2017, on the following:
`
`
`
`The Honorable Lisa R. Barton
`Secretary
`U.S. International Trade Commission
`500 E Street, S.W.
`Washington, D.C. 20436
`
`The Honorable David P. Shaw
`Administrative Law Judge
`U.S. International Trade Commission
`500 E Street, S.W.
`Washington, D.C. 20436
`
`Patricia Chow
`Attorney Advisor
`U.S. International Trade Commission
`500 E Street, S.W.
`Washington, D.C. 20436
`patricia.chow@usitc.gov
`
`
`Adam D. Swain
`ALSTON & BIRD LLP
`950 F Street, NW
`Washington, DC 20004-1404
`Telephone: (202)-239-3300
`Facsimile: (202) 654-4842
`Diebold.ITC@alston.com
`
`Counsel for Respondents Diebold,
`Incorporated and Diebold Self Service
`Systems
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` Via First Class Mail
` Via Hand Delivery
` Via Federal Express
` Via Electronic Filing
`
` Via First Class Mail
` Via Hand Delivery
` Via Federal Express
` Via Electronic Filing
` Via First Class Mail
` Via Hand Delivery
` Via Federal Express
` Via Electronic Mail
`
` Via First Class Mail
` Via Hand Delivery
` Via Federal Express
` Via Electronic Mail
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
`
` /s/ Eckqualyn Hedges
`
`
`
`
`
`